- THE DEFINITIVE EDITION
Ewan McGregor, Ewen Bremner, Robert Carlyle, Jonny Lee Miller
hard to think of a film that had more impact here in the UK during the 90s
than Danny Boyle's Trainspotting.
The film was based on
a novel by Irvine Welsh, about a group of young people struggling with relationships,
unemployment and drug addiction. The book and - especially - the film effectively captured the zeitgeist at the tail end of eighteen
years of Conservative rule, and seemed to provided a voice for a
disenfranchised subset of the population for whom climbing the social
ladder would have meant a step up from using to dealing.
The novel was
published in 1993, and quickly became a cultural phenomena, spawning a
stage adaptation, and, in March 1996, a hugely successful movie, directed
by Danny Boyle (who later directed The Beach and 28
Days Later). The film
broadened the novel's audience considerably, and launched a flood of
official and unofficial merchandise, including the year's must-wear
T-shirts, and a pair of best-selling soundtrack CDs. The film was helped
enormously by an innovative, aggressive, iconographic poster campaign and
a punchy trailer, both of which were widely imitated and parodied. Indeed,
their influence can still be seen today, nearly a decade later.
film, which cost £1.8m, became a cash cow for distributors Polygram,
which, over the years, was milked by various collector's edition-type VHS versions.
The film also elevated several of
its stars to A-list status, and helped to open doors for many of its
less prominent cast members (the very deserving Kelly McDonald, for
The film was even a
huge hit in the US, where subtitles helped to decipher the more impenetrable
sections of Edinburgh burr. It opened on a mere eight screens, but went on
to gross more than $16m.
DVD's anamophic 1.85:1 transfer is very acceptable, with good contrast and
detail. It's tempting to remember the film as having a subdued and grimy
palette, but in fact the film is peppered with bold splashes of colour,
which are nicely captured on the DVD. There's a smattering of
(positive) film and negative dirt artefacts throughout the print, but
nothing too distracting. Edge enhancement is present, and frequently
results in aliasing (jagged diagonal edges) and ringing on areas of high contrast.
There are no obvious signs of MPEG compression or excessive video noise
reduction, though. The layer change is poorly situated, and interrupts a music cue. The
disc's average bitrate is a very high 8.85Mb/s. One more observation:
there's a lot of film weave (slight movement of the image inside the
frame). It's not something most viewers are likely to notice under normal viewing
conditions, but it can be distracting. There are also slight hops on many
of the cuts, which is a problem that perhaps should have been addressed.
Purists will be happy
that the film's idiosyncratic subtitles (during the disco scene) and other
captions ("the worst [Toilet] in Scotland") have been retained (and aren't player-generated subtitles).
Unfortunately the disc prohibits the use of the popular
"bookmark" facility which some players offer.
Early VHS releases of Trainspotting
had 14" of BBFC cuts to a scene where Renton injects himself with
heroin, but these were waived and the footage was reinstated in 2002. This
DVD version of the
film is uncut.
audio options are available: a full-bitrate DTS version (at 1536kbps) and
Dolby Digital 5.1 version (at 448kbps). A sampling of both versions
indicates that the differences are subtle, but the DTS version offers
better definition and separation. Both versions are clean, and offer good
Universal's two-disc Trainspotting
- The Definitive Edition very nearly lives up to its billing, offering
more than anyone with a passing admiration for the film will be willing to
absorb, and almost enough to satisfy it's most dedicated fans. Some of the
supplements, including nine deleted scenes and the commentary track, have
been available before, but these have been supplemented with a lot of
newly-shot material. A 1997 essay by Irvine Walsh about the film,
commissioned for the 1997 Criterion laserdisc release, is featured in a
very attractive fold-out booklet supplied with the DVD, incidentally.
The first disc
contains the film, the commentary track and a ten-minute featurette, The
Beginning, which includes contemporary interviews with various
cast members, and some clips from the film which show how bad it might have looked, if Universal hadn't
one has an option to watch the film with
Follow-The-White-Rabbit-style branching, where a scissors icon will appear
on screen to denote the availability of a deleted scene. These sequences are,
inferior quality, and often look roughly-assembled, but at least are anamorphic, and so there's not a jarring jump in aspect ratio each time
one appears. A menu
option allows access to each deleted scene separately, with or without commentary
from Danny Boyle. Annoyingly, there's no "play all" option for
the deleted scenes, which means watching all nine, with and without
commentary, is very fiddly.
The deleted scenes includes choice moments like Renton's
attending a job interview, where he admits to a serious drug habit, and
two scenes which reveal the fate of Swanney (Peter Mullan). None of the deleted
scenes add much to the story, but most of them are nice character-building
moments. Several, it seems, were only removed because of an overriding
desire to keep the film about ninety-minutes long. It's also noted that
it's difficult to keep track of so many characters, and include a suitable
conclusion for each of them, in such a short film. In Trainspotting, as
in life, people often drift away before you've noticed they're gone.
film's commentary track was recorded in 1996 for Criterion's NTSC
laserdisc release. Criterion rarely licenses its disc content to other
they seem more flexible about releasing it outside the US, so getting the
commentary is something of a coup for Universal, and a boon for fans of
the movie, who might otherwise have had to hang on to their laserdisc
version. The track, by Danny Boyle, producer Andrew MacDonald, writer John
Hodge and star Ewan McGregor, is exemplary, offering plenty of information
about the production process. It reveals how some decisions were forced on
them by the lack of budget (the scene of Renton and Sick Boy in the park
would have been more elaborate, if they'd had the money to license the Mission:
Impossible theme, for example), and about how the book was changed quite
radically from the novel, whilst retaining its essence.
The bulk of the bonus
material is on the second disc. This is broken down into several sections:
- Look of the Film (Then and Now)
A contemporary interview with Production Designer Kave Quinn, showing
scrapbooks that were used as inspiration for the look and feel of the film
Interviews from February 2003, with Danny Boyle, Andrew MacDonald and John
Hodge, paying tribute to Quinn's work (3m).
Sound of the Film (Then and Now)
Primarily an interview with Danny Boyle conducted at Shepperton Studios in 1995,
during post-production. Boyle and MacDonald discuss the use of pop
music in the film (briefly showing how two different music tracks can
suggest completely different interpretations of a scene), and how he the
film's songs were assembled (David Bowie gave the project his blessing
early on, and other artists quickly followed). (8m)
More 2003 interviews, discussing the effect that the film had on the
popularity of the songs, and the artists involved (5m).
with Irvine Walsh, (5m, shot during the filming of his cameo), John Hodge
(8m, on adapting the novel for the screen, and his subsequent career),
Danny Boyle (11m, on all sorts of subjects, including casting the lead
actors; the portrayal of drug use in the film; it's critical reception; and how he's tried not to cash
in by repeating Trainspotting's formula) and Andrew MacDonald (10m,
reflecting on the marketing and release of the film, and its subsequent
effect on the British film industry).
Danny Boyle interview contains a deviously-hidden Easter Egg: when Boyle
talks about Muriel Grey, pressing "enter" leads to a selection
of press reviews (including a nice cartoon of Robert Carlyle).
Behind the Needle
minutes of behind
the scenes footage of the controversial scene where Renton injects himself
with heroin. The footage is presented three ways: the raw footage, Danny
Boyle watching the footage and offering commentary, and both
together. (Actually there are six options: all of the above either
full-frame, or, rather pointlessly, in a small box on the menu screen).
section also offers a 30" clip of Ewan McGregor, discussing the
Calton Athletic Boys, reformed junkies who acted as technical advisors on
carpet reactions from Martin Landau (1m), Noel Gallagher (2m), Damon
Albarn (1m) and Ewan McGregor (1m).
Snapshot - two minutes of footage from the Cannes Trainspotting party,
including contributions from The Sixth Sense's Toni Collette,
critic Jon Ronson, musician Dave Stewart and Miramax head honcho Harvey Weinstein.
Teaser Trailer (1m, which features some especially-shot footage of Ewan
McGregor tied to a railway track)) and the Theatrical Trailer (2m,
including a censored version of the "Choose..." speech). Both
are presented in full-frame format, and are of relatively mediocre
The second disc also
brief text biographies for most of the cast members, and the key
production staff, and a
montage of Polaroids, set to Sleeper's cover version of Blondie's Atomic
array of bonus materials offered is impressive, but it's not Definitive.
Earlier releases included a related music video (for Underworld's Born
Slippy), and an extended selection of deleted scenes, which were
accidentally added to the first pressing of one of the VHS box sets.
However, what has been included should satisfy most viewers. In addition
to a fair amount of contemporary behind the scenes footage, three key
contributors (Boyle, Hodge and MacDonald) have made themselves available
to offer a lot of new material. The commentary track can't be faulted, and
adds Ewan McGregor's voice to the mix. It would have been nice to
see something from a more objective perspective, however: a short featurette on
the film's enormous cultural impact, perhaps. Contributions from some of
the more neglected cast members would also have been welcome. Niggles
aside, Universal's Trainspotting - The Definitive Edition deserves
to be in the collection of any serious film fan, or anyone who grew up as
part of what we may yet come to call the Trainspotting generation.